Church staff

Rev. Dr. Stephen Caine

Presbyterian Pastor

Ext. 305

Hello, I am Stephen Caine, one of the Pastors here at The Indian Hill Church and I hope that you and your family will come and visit us for worship and fellowship and that you can find what is so special about us. I am a Co-Pastor or the Presbyterian Teaching Elder of the Indian Hill Church. I started in December 2013. Prior to that I served as Pastor Head of Staff of the First Presbyterian Church of Shelbyville, Tennessee. Prior to serving in Shelbyville, I was pastor of The Marion Presbyterian Church, Marion, South Carolina for four years. I am the second of four boys and I was raised in Signal Mountain, Tennessee. I graduated in 1996 from Columbia Theological Seminary, in Decatur, Georgia. While at Columbia Seminary I met my wife, Margaret Adams Caine (Monnie), who is also an ordained Teaching Elder (Minister of the Word and Sacrament) in the PC (USA). Our family includes two sons, Winston, Marion and a daughter Elliott. Apart from my work at the church I have a range of other interests. My leisure activities include reading, sports of all types, coaching my children’s sports teams, community and civic volunteer work, watching movies, yard work, eating at good restaurants and spending time with my family and friends.

Rev. Meredith day hearn

Episcopal priest in charge

Ext. 304

Meredith joined the staff of The Indian Hill Church as Episcopal Priest-in-Charge in August of 2020. Prior to her appointment at Indian Hill, Meredith served as Curate for Christian Formation and Congregational Development at Grace-St. Luke’s Episcopal Church and School in Memphis, Tennessee. Before she was ordained in 2018, she served as the Director of Youth Formation and Bible teacher at GSL. Meredith is from Fort Worth, Texas. She received her Bachelor of Arts in Religious Studies at Belmont University in Nashville, Tennessee, focusing especially on the integration of religion and the arts. After her undergraduate studies, she continued her education and spiritual formation at Yale Divinity School earning a Master of Divinity and certificate from the Yale Institute of Sacred Music in 2015. Meredith and her husband, Jackson, recently moved to the Cincinnati area where make their home in the Clifton neighborhood. She enjoys watching movies, spending time in nature, baking, and scouring the city for best Mexican food in town.

Jennifer Taylor

Director of children and family ministry

Ext. 307

Jennifer has been the Director of Children and Family Ministries at the Indian Hill Church since September 2012.  Jennifer holds a BS in Biomedical Science from Texas A&M University.  She was raised and confirmed in a Presbyterian church and was later confirmed as an adult in the Episcopal Church. Jennifer previously worked for First Presbyterian Church, Houston for 7 years in both Early Childhood Coordinator and Elementary Coordinator roles.  Jennifer and her family moved to Indian Hill in 2010. Her hobbies include watching her three boy’s soccer, swimming, lacrosse and baseball games, volunteering at school, reading and gardening.

Phil Clary

Director of Music

Phil is the church’s Director of Music and has been with Indian Hill Church since August 2017.  He is from Cincinnati, where his undergraduate work was at Northern Kentucky University and his graduate studies were at Xavier University.  Before joining the staff at IHC, Phil served parishes in several denominations, with 18 of those years being in the Episcopal Church.  Phil is visible in the community as a teacher in the Music Department at Indian Hill High school and as the Artistic Director of the Cincinnati Choral Society.  He currently sings with the Cincinnati Fusion Ensemble and sang in the Vocal Arts Ensemble for several seasons.  Phil and his wife, Erin, enjoy travel, theater, coffee, good food and wine, and are active in hosting foreign exchange students with YFU (Youth for Understanding).

Amy Clark

Youth Director/Assistant Director of Music

Ext. 312

Amy Clark, originally from Akron, OH, came to Cincinnati in 2002 where she earned a B.S. in Music Education and a B.A. in Vocal Performance from Xavier University. She taught general music at St. Vivian School for grades K-8 for four years. For the past seven years she has been the Director of Vocal Music at Ursuline Academy, where she conducted three choral ensembles, taught music theory, and was the vocal music director during the musical productions. Additionally while at Ursuline she went on several service trips to Re-Member on the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota, as well as volunteering on other service projects, including Shantytown, and went on several Kairos retreats. Amy has been singing at IHC with the Adult, Women’s, and Youth Choirs for the past two years. She also produced the last two Christmas productions with grades K-8 here at IHC, as well as the Spring Music with the students in grades K-8. She is so excited to be a full time member of the IHC team and cannot wait to get started as the Youth Director and Assistant Director of Music!


Jocelyn tozier

Director of Indian Hill Church Nursery

(513) 561-5513

Jocelyn Tozier has been with the IHC since 2014. Jocelyn attended University of Dayton and received her Masters of Science in Education with a focus in early childhood education and intervention specialist. Jocelyn also holds a Bachelor of Science in Human Development and Family Science from The Ohio State University. Jocelyn has worked in the field of early childhood education since 2004, starting out her career as an infant teacher in Columbus, Ohio. Since then Jocelyn has taught toddler and preschool children as well. In addition to teaching, Jocelyn was an  Educational Coordinator and Preschool Director before becoming the School Director at IHCNS.

Bill Koons

Church Sexton

Ext. 308

Bill joined Indian Hill Church in 2017 as a full-time employee and is an integral part of our team in keeping the building/grounds in pristine condition. Bill served in the Army Infantry for 9 years and is a Veteran of Desert Storm – we salute and appreciate his service and are blessed to have him at IHC.